Money Arguments and Divorce: The "Top Predictor" Line Came From a Press Release
The famous line is a quote in a 2013 press release. The paper is paywalled, and a co-author's other 2012 paper calls money only mildly predictive of divorce.
Before the article, one note that belongs at the top rather than the bottom. There is a difference between arguing about money and having money used against you. Controlling a partner's access to money, taking their wages, running up debt in their name, demanding receipts for ordinary spending, or stopping someone from working or studying are patterns of economic abuse, not disagreements about a budget — and in that situation nothing on this page applies. The National Domestic Violence Hotline, linked in the sources below, describes those patterns, and is reachable in the United States at 1-800-799-7233 or by texting START to 88788, around the clock. Find A Helpline lists free and confidential services by country. If money is being used to control you, that is the thing to get help with first.
With that said. If you have searched for money arguments and divorce you have met the same sentence everywhere, usually in quotation marks: arguments about money are by far the top predictor of divorce — not children, not sex, not in-laws. It is quoted by news outlets, by magazines, by university extension blogs and by a notable number of divorce law firms.
It was said out loud, by one of three authors, in a Kansas State University press release dated 12 July 2013, about a paper published in 2012. This page is what happens when you go looking for the paper, the survey it used, and the studies around it.
Four things turned up. The paper is paywalled, with no legal free copy anywhere, so essentially nobody repeating the claim has read it. The survey behind it asked about seven disagreement topics including "the children," but every open account of this line of work uses a five-topic set that leaves both child items out — so the comparison the quote asserts has no visible published test. An open-access companion paper by the same first author, on the same survey, reports that disagreements about housework predicted conflict tactics as strongly as money did in five of its eight analyses. And the same co-author published a second paper that same year, free in her own university's repository, concluding that money arguments are "only mildly predictive of divorce" — in a model where having children ranked above money.
There is also a cleaner study that nobody cites: 100 couples kept diaries of every argument for fifteen days, and money came fifth or sixth. The most common fight was about the children. The same couples, asked in a lab to name their hardest topic, said money.
What follows is sixteen sections: where the sentence came from, what the survey asked word for word, what its own published frequencies show, the companion papers, the one real effect size and the conference paper it came from, the diary study, why recall and diaries disagree, what divorced people say ended their marriages, the strongest honest version of the money claim, the part that survives, what money arguments are actually about, and the version of the question that has an answer. Our editorial policy explains why every figure here carries a linked source, and why the places where the evidence contradicts itself are named rather than smoothed over.
The sentence everyone repeats, and the page it was actually published on
Search for money and divorce and you will meet the same sentence, usually inside quotation marks, usually without a link:
"Arguments about money is by far the top predictor of divorce. It's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else. It's money — for both men and women."
It is a real quote and it is correctly attributed. Sonya Britt, then an assistant professor of family studies and human services at Kansas State University, said it in a Kansas State press release dated 12 July 2013. The release is no longer on the university's own site — the URL returns 404 — but ScienceDaily carries it in full, credited to Kansas State, under the headline Early financial arguments are a predictor of divorce.
Notice the gap between the headline and the quote. The headline says a predictor. The quote says by far the top predictor. Both are on the same page, about the same study.
Notice the grammar, too: arguments about money is. That is a sentence somebody spoke, transcribed as spoken. It is not a line from a paper, and nobody citing it has ever claimed it was — they just stopped mentioning where it came from.
The study underneath it is real and specific: Jeffrey Dew, Sonya Britt and Sandra Huston, Examining the Relationship Between Financial Issues and Divorce, published in Family Relations 61(4), 615-628, in 2012 — a year before the press release. It analysed the National Survey of Families and Households, with N = 4,574 couples, which the press rounded to "more than 4,500."
This page is what happens when you try to check the sentence against the paper, against the survey's own published codebook, against the open-access companion papers by the same authors on the same data, and against the three other literatures that have measured the same question a different way. One of those sources is a second paper Britt published in 2012, the same year, which reaches a visibly weaker conclusion. Our editorial policy explains why every figure here carries a linked source.
The paper it comes from cannot be read without paying
Start with the thing that shapes everything below: almost nobody repeating this claim has read the study, and most of them could not.
Family Relations is a Wiley journal and this article is closed. Unpaywall, the service that indexes legal free copies of paywalled articles, returns `is_oa: false` for the DOI and lists zero open locations. Semantic Scholar records its open-access status as `CLOSED`. There is a record in Brigham Young University's repository, where the first author now works, but the full-text link on it points at a university library proxy rather than a public file. A copy indexed by CORE returns 403 Forbidden.
So the chain runs: a 2012 paywalled article → a 2013 press release quoting one of its three authors → a decade of pages quoting the press release. Everyone after step two is working from a spoken summary.
What the abstract says is public, and it is worth putting next to the quote, because the two are not the same claim. The abstract reports that "both wives' and husbands' financial disagreements were the strongest disagreement types to predict divorce," and concludes that "financial disagreements are stronger predictors of divorce relative to other common marital disagreements." It also reports that when financial disagreements were in the model, financial well-being was no longer associated with divorce, and that conflict tactics and marital satisfaction fully mediated the association between financial disagreement and the hazard of divorce.
Strongest of the disagreement types measured is a defensible, bounded finding. By far the top predictor of divorce — not children, sex, in-laws or anything else is a claim about everything that predicts divorce. The first is in the abstract. The second was said out loud.
And "fully mediated" matters more than it sounds. It means the paper's own model says money arguments do not act on divorce directly: they act by changing how couples fight and how satisfied they are. The mechanism is the fight, not the subject of the fight — which is the whole premise of the research on how couples repair after an argument.
Because the article is closed, this page does not report a single number from inside it. Everything numerical below comes from sources anyone can open: the survey's published codebook, two open-access papers by the same authors on the same data, and four open studies that asked the question differently.
What the survey actually asked, word for word
The National Survey of Families and Households is the data behind the claim, and its codebook is free on the University of Wisconsin's servers. The disagreement battery is item E706 of the Wave 1 self-administered form, and here is its stem, verbatim:
"The following is a list of subjects on which couples often have disagreements. How often, if at all, in the last year have you had open disagreements about each of the following:"
And here are the subjects, verbatim, in the order the form lists them:
- a. household tasks
- b. money
- c. spending time together
- d. sex
- e. having a(nother) child
- f. in-laws
- g. the children
Seven items. The response scale runs `01-Never` in the past year, `02-Less than once a month`, `03-Several times a month`, `04-About once a week`, `05-Several times a week`, `06-Almost everyday`.
Three things follow from reading the instrument rather than the coverage.
It is a single question, asked once, about the past year. Not a diary, not an observation, not a count of actual arguments. It is a person's summary impression of twelve months, which is a different kind of measurement from the ones in the two sections after next, and the difference turns out to decide the answer.
"The children" is on the list. Item (g), in those words. So is item (e), "having a(nother) child," which is a separate thing — whether to have one, not how to raise the ones you have. Keep both in mind for the next section but one.
The survey is old. Wave 1 was collected in 1987-88 and Wave 2 in 1992-94. The couples whose answers produce the famous sentence were married in the Reagan and Bush years, before online banking, before two-earner households were the default, before most of the ways couples now hold money existed. Dew's own open companion paper names this as a limitation in plain terms: "it is an older data set. Marriage relations may have changed since 1992."
That is not a gotcha — the NSFH is used because it is one of very few national longitudinal surveys that asked both spouses about conflict tactics, fight topics and actual assets and debt. It is the right data for the question. It is also data about a marriage that no longer quite exists, the same caveat that applies to the numbers that circulate about modern dating.
Money is first by one measure and third by another
The codebook publishes the raw response distribution for each of the seven topics, which means the first part of the claim can simply be checked. The figures below are our own arithmetic on the codebook's unweighted Wave 1 frequencies, counting everyone who gave a substantive answer. They are survey-wide marginals, not the analysis sample of any paper.
Share reporting any disagreement at all in the past year:
- money — 59.8%
- household tasks — 59.0%
- the children — 55.4%
- spending time together — 49.7%
- sex — 38.6%
- in-laws — 30.2%
- having a(nother) child — 9.7%
Money is first. By 0.8 of a percentage point, over household tasks, in a sample of about 6,300 answers. That is the empirical content of "money is what couples fight about most": a lead of under one point over doing the dishes.
Now ask the same data who fights often rather than ever, by counting only the answers of about once a week or more:
- spending time together — 11.6%
- the children — 10.8%
- money — 9.6%
- household tasks — 8.7%
- sex — 7.2%
- in-laws — 3.4%
- having a(nother) child — 1.5%
Money is third. Spending time together and the children both outrank it, and the gap at the top of this table is wider than the gap at the top of the one above.
The two tables are not in conflict and neither is wrong. They measure different things. Money disagreements are widely distributed — nearly everybody has a few — while disagreements about time together and about children are concentrated: fewer couples have them, and the couples who do have them constantly. "What do most couples argue about at least once?" and "what do couples argue about most often?" have different answers in the same question of the same survey.
Which of those two a page reports decides whether money looks like the number one issue in marriage. Both are available free, in the same table, and neither appears on any page competing for this question.
The comparison that would settle "it's not children" was not run
The quote names three things money allegedly beats: children, sex, in-laws. Two of those three are worth following up, and the first one is the problem.
The survey has seven disagreement items, including "the children" and "having a(nother) child." The analyses published on this data use five.
This is documented twice. Dew's own open companion paper, which is next in this article, states its independent variables outright: "These topics were 'money,' 'household tasks,' 'spending time together,' 'sex,' and 'in-laws.'" Five. Both child items are absent.
And the one detailed scholarly description of the 2012 divorce paper's measure gives the same five. Writing in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships in 2023, Johanna Peetz and colleagues summarise it: "Couples rated the frequency of disagreements about various topics in their relationship, such as chores, finances, time spent together, sex, and in-law relations."
Two honest caveats about what that does and does not establish. Peetz's list is introduced with "such as," so it is a description rather than a complete inventory of the model. And because the 2012 article is paywalled, we cannot open it and check its own table. What can be said precisely is this: the survey contains a children item, every open account of this line of work uses a five-topic set that excludes it, and no public source we can find shows the children items ever being entered into the comparison. The sentence "it's not children" is an assertion about a contrast for which there is no visible published test.
The second thing Peetz's sentence reports is more direct, and it contradicts the quote without any ambiguity: "Only frequency of disagreements about finances and sex were significant predictors of divorce 5-7 years later."
Sex was significant. The quote says "it's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else." In the description of the paper's own results, sex is one of the two topics that survived.
That pattern — a claim that a thing beats all rivals, where one named rival was also significant and another was never entered — is the same shape as the famous in-law figure, where half the quoted pair is in the paper and the other half was manufactured by the coverage: what the research on in-laws and divorce actually found.
The companion paper, same data, same author: housework ties with money
There is a paper on the same survey, by the same first author, published a year earlier, that is free to read in full and that does exactly the comparison the famous quote claims to summarise. Nobody cites it.
Jeffrey Dew and John Dakin published Financial Disagreements and Marital Conflict Tactics in the Journal of Financial Therapy 2(1), 23-42, in 2011, under a Creative Commons licence. Same NSFH waves. 5,362 couples cross-sectionally, 3,861 longitudinally. The same five disagreement topics. And rather than lumping the non-money topics together, as earlier work had, they put each one in the model against money — which is precisely what you need to do to say money beats the others.
Here are their standardised coefficients for predicting the frequency of heated arguments, which is the conflict tactic most clearly tied to marital outcomes. W = wife's report, H = husband's report:
- Money (H) — .14
- Housework (W) — .13
- Housework (H) — .11
- Money (W) — .09
- In-laws (W) — .05
- Sex (H) — .03
- In-laws (H) — .03
- Spousal time (W) — .03
- Spousal time (H) — .02
- Sex (W) — .01
Read the top of that table. Husbands' money disagreements lead at .14. Wives' housework disagreements are second at .13, ahead of wives' money disagreements at .09. Money and housework are interleaved, not ranked.
The authors say so themselves, and they say it twice. In the abstract: "Contrary to previous studies, however, disagreements over housework also predicted conflict tactics about as strongly as financial disagreements." And in the discussion, after reporting the findings the way everyone else would: "So far, we have reported the findings as if financial disagreements are the strongest predictor of conflict tactics. In fact, in five of the eight analyses, disagreements over housework are as strong of predictors of conflict tactics as financial disagreements."
Five of eight. By the same team, on the same data, in a journal that costs nothing to open. If housework matches money that closely as a source of heated argument, the obvious next question is whether the division of it predicts anything about whether couples last — and the two national studies usually quoted for that turn out to point in opposite directions: what splitting the housework actually predicts.
Two more things in this paper deserve lifting out, because one supports the press release and one undercuts it.
Supporting it: income, assets and consumer debt all carry coefficients of about .01 and none reaches significance. Britt's claim that "it didn't matter how much you made or how much you were worth" is the one part of her quote that the open evidence backs cleanly. Money arguments are not a proxy for poverty.
Undercutting it: the authors tested the arrow and could not straighten it. Regressing changes in financial arguments on changes in conflict style, they found that "change in heated arguments and changes in the difference between heated arguments and calm discussion did predict changes in the frequency of financial disagreements," and concluded: "we cannot totally rule out a reverse-directional relationship." Couples who start fighting worse may simply start fighting about money more. Their own closing limitation is blunter still: "the effect sizes are not as large as we expected."
Which of money or housework is "the" topic also turns out to be a question with its own research tradition and its own contradictory national studies, and it is the next thing this site is looking at.
The co-author's own other 2012 paper calls it "only mildly predictive of divorce"
This is the single most awkward document in the record, and it is by the person who said the sentence.
Sonya Britt and Sandra Huston published The Role of Money Arguments in Marriage in the Journal of Family and Economic Issues 33(4), 464-476, in 2012 — the same year as the Family Relations paper, with two of the same three authors. The accepted manuscript is free in Kansas State's own repository, K-REx. Different data: the 1979 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, following married women over more than two decades. The money-arguments item was only asked of female respondents, so the sample is married women in a first marriage: N = 717 for the satisfaction model, N = 966 for the divorce model.
Its opening page quotes another scholar approvingly, and the quote is this: "virtually no studies exist that support the still popular belief that financial problems are the number one cause of divorce."
Its conclusion is this: "money arguments are highly predictive of low relationship satisfaction and only mildly predictive of divorce."
And its discussion is this: "Note, however, that money arguments are much larger contributors to low relationship satisfaction than divorce. The only predictive measure of money arguments leading to divorce was a frequent level of arguments in the early years of marriage."
That last sentence is doing a lot of work. In the divorce model, of the four money-argument variables tested, exactly one was significant. Reporting that you argued about money "often" early on raised the odds of divorce — odds ratio 2.62, p < .05. Reporting that you never argued about money was not significant. An increase in money arguments over the marriage was not significant. A decrease was not significant. General arguing about many topics was not significant in any form.
Now the part that bears directly on "it's not children." The paper ranks its predictors of divorce by standardised coefficient, and money arguments come fourth:
1. Marital duration (β = −2.94; OR 0.53) — "most predictive of whether a respondent divorced" 2. Age at marriage (β = −2.66; OR 0.46) — "the second most predictive variable in the model" 3. Having children during the marriage (β = −0.43; OR 0.15) — "the third most predictive factor," and these respondents were "approximately 85% less likely to divorce" 4. Often arguing about money at marriage (β = 0.19; OR 2.62) — "the fourth largest contributor to the model" 5. Spouses of similar age (β = −0.19; OR 0.41)
In Britt's own analysis, published the same year she said money beats everything, children beat money. Having children during the marriage was a larger contributor to the divorce model than money arguments were. So did how long people had been married, and so did how old they were when they married — the variable whose own famous number is examined in the best age to get married.
It is worth being fair about what this does and does not show. These are two different datasets, two different outcome windows and two different model specifications, and nothing requires them to agree. A researcher can hold that one paper's design answers the question better than another's. What is hard to defend is the public sentence, because "by far the top predictor of divorce — not children" cannot be squared with a table in which children rank above money, published by the same author, in the same year, in a journal, with a free copy in her own university's repository.
The paper's own explanation for the split is the most useful idea in it: "It is possible that money arguments are not as predictive of divorce as they are in relationship satisfaction because spouses nearing divorce have lost the desire to try to work through their relationship problems." Arguing requires engagement. People on their way out frequently stop arguing — which is why a measure of fights can miss the marriages that have already ended internally, and why the research on why people stay in unhappy relationships keeps finding that stability and happiness are separate variables.
The one real number in circulation comes from a conference paper
Across every page we measured on this topic, exactly one gives a usable effect size, and it is not the one in the quote.
The number is: couples who disagreed about finances once a week were over 30 percent more likely to divorce over time than couples who disagreed about finances a few times a month.
It is a real figure with a traceable origin. Jeffrey Dew published it in Bank On It: Thrifty Couples are the Happiest, his essay in The State of Our Unions 2009, the National Marriage Project's annual report. That page is now offline at its original address and reachable through the Internet Archive.
The essay is more careful than anything downstream of it, and the specific sentences are worth having:
"For husbands, financial disagreements were the only type of common disagreement that predicted whether they would divorce. For wives, both financial and sexual disagreements predicted divorce, but financial disagreements were a much better predictor."
That is the honest shape of the finding: an asymmetry between husbands and wives, with sex also predicting divorce for wives. Not "it's not sex."
And then there is where the number comes from. Dew's footnote for it cites: Jeffrey P. Dew, "Financial issues as predictors of divorce." Paper presented at the annual conference of the National Council on Family Relations (November 2009). San Francisco, CA.
A conference paper. In 2009. That conference paper is what later became the 2012 Family Relations article. So the one quantified version of this claim entered the world through a conference presentation, was written up for a general-audience report by its own author, and reached a journal three years later behind a paywall — at which point the press release replaced the number with an adjective.
This is not a scandal. Presenting work at a conference and summarising it for a public report are ordinary, legitimate things to do, and Dew's own write-up was more measured than the coverage that followed. But it does mean something specific: for over a decade the public version of this claim has been less precise than the version its author published in 2009. There was a number and a gender asymmetry and a stated comparison group; the sentence that travelled kept none of them.
It is the same trajectory as the 11%-a-year divorce figure in the best age to get married, which also went from a careful self-published analysis into a decade of coverage that dropped every qualification, and as the 57% figure examined in the friends-first research.
In fifteen days of home diaries, the most common fight was about the children
There is one study that did not ask people to summarise a year, and it answers the frequency question directly.
Lauren Papp, E. Mark Cummings and Marcie Goeke-Morey published For Richer, for Poorer: Money as a Topic of Marital Conflict in the Home in Family Relations 58(1), 91-103, in 2009. It is free in PubMed Central. Method: 100 husbands and 100 wives kept a diary for 15 days, filling in a record after every instance of marital conflict at home, recording the topic, the length, whether it was an old problem, how it was handled and how resolved it felt. 748 conflicts were logged, and both spouses rated the overlapping ones.
Here is what they were actually fighting about, as a percentage of logged conflicts — husbands' reports first, then wives':
- Children — 36.4% / 38.9%
- Chores — 25.1% / 24.1%
- Communication — 22.1% / 21.8%
- Leisure — 19.5% / 20.1%
- Work — 19.3% / 18.9%
- Money — 18.3% / 19.4%
- Habits — 16.2% / 17.1%
- Relatives — 10.7% / 11.9%
- Commitment — 8.2% / 9.1%
- Intimacy — 7.9% / 8.4%
- Friends — 7.1% / 8.0%
- Personality — 5.5% / 8.6%
Money is sixth for husbands and fifth for wives. Children is first by a wide margin — roughly twice the rate of money — and chores, communication, leisure and work all come above it too. The authors state it in the abstract without hedging: "Contrary to findings from previous laboratory-based surveys, spouses did not rate money as the most frequent source of marital conflict in the home."
And yet this paper is one of the strongest pieces of evidence that money fights are distinctive, which is why it gets cited by everyone on the subject including Dew. What it found about the character of money conflicts, relative to non-money ones, held up:
- Wives described them as lasting longer.
- Husbands described them as more likely to be a recurrent rather than a new problem.
- Both rated them as having higher current and long-term importance to the relationship.
- Husbands expressed more angry behaviour in them; both partners expressed more depressive behaviour — physical distress, withdrawal, sadness, fear.
- Both were more likely to end them by agreeing to discuss it later, which is to say unresolved, despite wives attempting more explicit problem-solving in them.
Their summary: money conflicts "were more pervasive, problematic, and recurrent, and remained unresolved, despite including more attempts at problem solving."
So the defensible claim about money is not that it is the most common fight. It is that money is the fight that does not finish. That is a claim about resolution, not frequency, and it points at the pattern our conflict style test is built to score: what happens when one person keeps raising something and the other keeps deferring it.
The limits, stated as the authors state them: 100 couples, all parents of a child between 8 and 16, 93-94% white, recruited through schools and local advertising in one American region, married an average of 12 years. And the data are concurrent — "causal statements cannot be made about the direction of the effects." The children result in particular is a sample artefact as much as a finding, and the authors say so: these were couples in the thick of raising teenagers, who "may, in fact," have children as their most common source of conflict for that reason.
Why the surveys and the diaries disagree, and which one to believe
Two good studies, two answers. In a national survey asking about the past year, money comes first. In fifteen days of real-time diaries, money comes fifth or sixth. That gap is the most interesting finding in this whole literature and it has a worked-out explanation.
Papp and colleagues ran the test themselves, inside the same study, and the result is the thing to take away from this page.
Before the diary phase, they brought the same couples into a lab and asked them to list three topics that were typically hard to work through, as a prelude to a problem-solving discussion. Asked that way:
- Husbands rated money first, then childrearing, then balancing work and home.
- Wives rated childrearing first, then money, then balancing work and home.
Then the couples chose together which topic to actually discuss on camera. "The most common issue actually discussed in this laboratory context was money, followed by childrearing and recreation."
So the same 100 couples produced money-first when asked to summarise, and money-fifth when they wrote down what had just happened at home. The authors' conclusion is the one sentence that explains the entire genre: "laboratory problem-solving tasks may lead to an overestimation of the frequency of money conflicts."
They offer three reasons, and all three are checkable against how the measurements differ.
Recurrence masquerades as frequency. Money conflicts are the ones that keep coming back unresolved. A topic raised for the fifth time about the same unsettled problem feels like the dominant issue in a marriage, even if four other topics each came up more often in the past fortnight. Asked to summarise a year, people report salience; asked what happened tonight, they report incidence.
Money is the respectable thing to admit fighting about. This is their sharpest point, borrowed from Furnham and Argyle: money "may be among the most 'socially acceptable' topics that people can admit arguing about." In a lab, on a form, to an interviewer, we argue about money is a sentence with no shame in it. We argue about sex, I think they are a bad parent, I do not feel they like me very much are not. A self-report instrument measures what people will say, and money is unusually easy to say.
The format invites it. When a couple must pick one topic to discuss on camera, they will pick the one that is substantive but least exposing. Money qualifies perfectly.
And this matters for the famous sentence specifically, because the NSFH item behind it is a retrospective self-report of the past year — the exact instrument the diary study shows overestimates money. The quote is built on the measurement format whose bias in favour of money has been demonstrated, by one of the papers it cites.
None of which means the survey result is false. The NSFH is national and large and the diary study is 100 regional couples; each is better than the other at something. It means the honest reading is narrower than either: money is the topic couples most readily report, and the topic they least often finish. Whether it is the topic they most often raise depends on how you ask, and the two ways of asking give different answers on purpose.
The same divide between what people report about a relationship and what is happening in it runs through what the research on emotional openness found and through the habits of couples who stay in love.
When people are asked why they divorced, money is not at the top
A third literature asks the question from the other end: people whose marriages have already ended, asked what ended them. Money does not come first in any of them.
Scott, Rhoades, Stanley, Allen and Markman (2013), in Couple and Family Psychology 2(2), 131-145, free in PubMed Central. They tracked down 52 individuals who had taken a premarital education programme and divorced within the following 14 years, and asked which items from a list had been a "major contributor" to the divorce:
- Lack of commitment — 75.0%
- Infidelity — 59.6%
- Too much conflict and arguing — 57.7%
- Marrying too young — 45.1%
- Financial problems — 36.7%
- Substance abuse — 34.6%
- Domestic violence — 23.5%
Fifth. And their participants volunteered the distinction that matters: "some participants indicated that financial difficulties were not the most pertinent reason for their divorce, but instead contributed to increased stress and tension within the relationship." Others reported that the financial trouble was itself downstream of something else — an illness, a job loss, a substance problem.
Amato and Previti (2003) asked divorced people the open-ended version — why did your marriage end? — and coded the answers. Infidelity came first (21.6%), then incompatibility (19.2%), then drinking or drug use (10.6%). Financial problems came 13th of 18 themes, named by 2% of the sample. We report that ranking as Britt and Huston's own 2012 paper reports it, in its literature review, two pages before the sentence about money being the number one cause.
Hawkins, Willoughby and Doherty (2012), as reported by Scott and colleagues, surveyed divorcing parents from a list of choices: growing apart (55%), not being able to talk together (53%), and how one's spouse handled money (40%) — third.
A statewide Oklahoma survey (Johnson and colleagues, 2001), same source: lack of commitment (85%), too much conflict or arguing (61%), infidelity (58%).
Four studies, four methods, four rankings. Money lands third, fifth, 13th, and outside the top three. It is consistently present and never first.
The obvious objection to all of this is correct and needs saying: stated reasons are unreliable. People do not have accurate access to why their marriage ended, they construct an account afterwards, and the account is shaped by what is sayable and what is blameable. The Scott study contains a beautiful illustration — 65.8% of men and 73.8% of women said their ex-spouse should have worked harder to save the marriage, while only 31.6% and 33.3% said they themselves should have. Nobody should treat these lists as causal.
But the unreliability cuts in a specific direction here, and it is the same direction the diary study found. If anything, self-report over-states money, because money is the blameless, structural, non-humiliating explanation. The measurement bias runs toward money, and money still does not come first.
And notice what does come first, repeatedly: lack of commitment, growing apart, not being able to talk, too much arguing. Those are the variables in what makes a relationship show real potential, and they are what the relationship satisfaction test is built to score.
The strongest version of the money claim, stated properly
Having taken the famous sentence apart, it is only fair to assemble the best case that money matters a great deal — because it exists, it is quantified, and it is not the claim anyone is making.
The strongest finding is not about arguments at all. It is about what one spouse thinks of how the other handles money.
In his 2009 essay, Dew reports from Amato and Rogers' 1997 longitudinal study: "in one study, feeling that one's spouse spent money foolishly increased the likelihood of divorce 45 percent for both men and women. Only extramarital affairs and alcohol/drug abuse were stronger predictors of divorce."
Read that carefully, because it is both much stronger and much more specific than the press release.
It is stronger. A 45% increase, symmetric across men and women, with only two things above it. That is a serious effect in a serious longitudinal design.
It is a different variable. Not how often you argue about money but whether you think your partner is foolish with it. Those are not the same thing. A couple can argue about money weekly as a form of joint management. A person can also silently conclude their partner is reckless and never raise it. The second is what predicted divorce here.
And it explicitly names two things that beat it. Affairs and substance abuse. "Only extramarital affairs and alcohol/drug abuse were stronger predictors" is the opposite of "it's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else." The most favourable number for money in this entire literature comes attached to a sentence placing it third.
One caveat we have to state: Amato and Rogers (1997), in the Journal of Marriage and the Family 59(3), is paywalled and we could not open it. The 45% figure and the ranking appear here as Dew reports them in a source anyone can read, not as something checked against the original. That is a weaker footing than the rest of this page and it is labelled as such.
Dew's essay carries a second figure in the same register, also worth having: "couples with no assets at the beginning of a 36 month period were 70 percent more likely to divorce than couples with $10,000 in assets." That is about having a financial cushion, not about fighting.
Put the real findings together and the picture is coherent, and it is not about arguing:
- Having no savings predicts divorce substantially.
- Thinking your partner is foolish with money predicts divorce substantially, behind affairs and substance abuse.
- Arguing about money predicts divorce modestly, mostly if it starts early, and in the one paper that modelled it against everything else it came fourth.
- Arguing about money predicts dissatisfaction strongly — Britt and Huston's odds ratios of 2.38 for frequent arguments and 2.44 for arguments that increase over the marriage are large, and that model is where their money variables did most of their work.
The last line is the one the coverage dropped, and it is the most useful one in the literature. Money arguments are a strong signal about how a relationship feels, and a weak-to-moderate one about whether it ends. Those are different questions, and the research answered the first one better — which is the same split found in the research on couples therapy, where what moves distress and what prevents breakup turn out to be measured separately.
The part that survives: it is the early arguments that count
One element of Britt's press-release quote holds up well, has independent support, and is almost never the part anybody repeats. It is this one:
"You can measure people's money arguments when they are very first married. It doesn't matter how long ago it was, but when they were first together and already arguing about money, there is a good chance they are going to have poor relationship satisfaction."
That is the finding her own paper actually supports. In Britt and Huston's divorce model, remember, the only significant money variable was frequent arguments in the early years of marriage — not the current level, not whether it got better, not whether it got worse. The timing was the whole result.
And there is independent evidence pointing the same way, from a very different design. Hannah Williamson, Teresa Nguyen, Benjamin Karney and Thomas Bradbury published Are problems that contribute to divorce present at the start of marriage, or do they emerge over time? in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 33(8), in 2016, free via the University of California's repository. They had rated problem lists from newlyweds at four points, then went back after divorces and asked which problems had contributed.
The result on money is unusually clean. For wives, of thirteen problems tested, "management of money" was the only one whose starting level differed by whether it later contributed to the divorce. Wives who said money had contributed had rated it 6.6 in difficulty at the start of the marriage; wives who said it had not rated it 3.2. Roughly twice as hard, from the beginning.
Six other problems for wives showed the opposite pattern — flat for the no-group, rising for the yes-group. Communication, quality of time together, personality, decision-making, unrealistic expectations, plans for the future: those got worse. Money did not have to. It was already there on day one.
The limitation here is severe and has to be stated loudly: this is a very small sample — 17 men and 23 women providing data at the first time point, falling to 5 and 7 by the fourth. A single-group finding from a sample that size is a lead, not a fact. We report it because it independently points the same way as Britt and Huston's timing result and because the design — ratings collected before anyone knew who would divorce — avoids the retrospective-account problem that limits the whole previous section. It is not because the sample can carry the weight.
Papp's diary data fit the same shape from a third direction: money was the topic husbands most often flagged as a recurrent rather than a new problem. Not the most frequent. The oldest.
So the version of the money claim with the most support across designs is also the least quotable: money trouble in a couple tends not to be something that develops. It tends to be something that was visible early and never got settled, and it shows up again and again because it never finished. That is a statement about an unresolved standing disagreement, which is a thing the questions that actually reveal compatibility are designed to surface before it becomes a decade of the same fight.
What money arguments are actually about, measured in 2023
Everything above treats "money" as one topic. The most recent work in this area breaks it open, and the result changes what the advice should be.
Johanna Peetz and colleagues published When couples fight about money, what do they fight about? in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 40(11), 3723-3751, in 2023. It is free in PubMed Central and the data are posted openly. Two studies. Study 1 thematically coded 988 posts from the r/relationships forum on Reddit describing a financial conflict — severe, ongoing, unresolved disputes. Study 2 recruited 481 married or long-term partnered people through MTurk in May-June 2022 and asked each to describe a recent financial disagreement — the mundane kind.
The themes sorted along two dimensions: concerns about fairness and concerns about responsibility. And when they checked the themes against measures of relationship satisfaction and of how understood people felt during the disagreement, the themes came apart sharply:
Associated with worse outcomes:
- Unfair relative contributions — who is putting in what. Lower couple satisfaction (p = .033, d = .35) and marginally lower perceived partner responsiveness.
- Job and income — whose work earns what. Lower couple satisfaction (p = .017, d = .56), the largest effect in the study.
- Perceived irresponsibility — one partner judged reckless, or hiding spending. Lower perceived responsiveness (p = .011, d = .23), though no difference in overall satisfaction.
Associated with better outcomes:
- Mundane expenses — the grocery bill, the small day-to-day decisions. Higher perceived responsiveness (p = .045, d = .22) and higher couple satisfaction (p = .016, d = .24).
That last line is the finding, and no page competing for this keyword contains it. People who described their recent money disagreement as being about ordinary expenses were doing better than average, not worse. A couple who bickers about the weekly shop is a couple running a joint household out loud.
So "arguing about money" is not one signal. It is at least two opposite signals wearing the same name. A disagreement about whether the division of contribution is fair, or about whether a partner can be trusted with shared resources, sits at the bad end. A disagreement about what to spend on dinner sits at the good end. Any claim of the form money arguments predict divorce has averaged those together — and all four of the older studies on this page used a single item that could not tell them apart. The NSFH asked how often you had open disagreements about "money." One word, for both of these things.
The limits are the ones you would expect and the authors name them: Reddit posts select for severe, stuck conflicts and come with no demographic information; the MTurk sample is 80.7% white, 96.7% married, mostly heterosexual, with a median relationship length of 13 years; the outcome measures are cross-sectional self-report, so none of this says which way the arrow points; and the effect sizes are small to moderate.
But it reframes the question usefully. "Do you fight about money?" turns out to be close to meaningless. "When you disagree about money, is it about fairness, about trust, or about groceries?" is a question with measured consequences attached — and it is the kind of distinction the conflict style test and the relationship satisfaction test are built around.
What the pages at the top of the results are built on
Measured today, the results for this question are a press release with a thirteen-year tail. What is competing: CTV News, HuffPost, Fortune, a university extension blog, and three divorce law firms. We could not get a clean first-page capture this time — Google returned its unusual-traffic challenge, and Brave, DuckDuckGo, its lite endpoint and Mojeek all returned bot checks or 403s, so what follows comes from the pages themselves rather than from a ranked list.
The pattern in them is consistent and worth itemising.
The news headline promoted the quote over the finding. CTV News ran "Fighting over money is a top predictor of divorce, study shows" on 16 July 2013, four days after the release. The headline treats the spoken superlative as the study's result.
The press release erased two of the three authors. The release says "Britt conducted a study." She is the second of three authors; Jeffrey Dew is first and the figure in circulation is originally his. By the time the claim reaches a law firm page, the erasure is complete: "Sonya Britt… conducted the study of 4,500 couples."
The most-linked pages are selling divorce. A representative example is a Los Angeles family law firm's post of 21 August 2013, Bad Pennies: Financial Arguments Top Predictor of Divorce, which quotes "It's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else. It's money – for both men and women" and closes: "As a family law attorney, I work with financial planners and family therapists regularly – contact me if you need a referral." A claim that money arguments are the leading sign your marriage is ending is being used as the top of a funnel for divorce representation.
And the lawyer was more careful than the press release. That same page says, in its second paragraph: "The actual causes of divorce are a bit more complicated," and goes on to list education, income, religious belief, infidelity, growing apart and unrealistic expectations. It is also the only page we found that reproduces Dew's actual effect size — the over-30-percent figure — rather than only the adjective.
Nobody cites the companion papers. Not one page we read mentions Dew and Dakin 2011, which is free and shows housework tying with money. Not one mentions Britt and Huston 2012, which is free in Kansas State's own repository and calls money arguments "only mildly predictive of divorce." Not one mentions Papp 2009, which is free in PubMed Central and found money fifth or sixth. Not one mentions Peetz 2023. The sentence has outlived every piece of evidence that qualifies it, including the evidence published by the people who said it.
That is the recurring shape of this genre: the modern dating statistics that nobody traces, the five love languages whose popular version outran its measurement by thirty years, the numbers attached to dating apps, and the figures about age gaps that were retracted and kept circulating. The claims that survive are the quotable ones, not the checkable ones, and our corrections page exists because that pressure applies here too.
The version of the question that has an answer
Are money arguments the top predictor of divorce? The honest answer is that the sentence is a press-release quote whose central comparison has no visible published test, and that the papers surrounding it — including two by its own authors — support something narrower and more useful.
What the evidence will carry, stated as tightly as it allows:
- Money is the topic couples most readily report disagreeing about, and in the survey behind the famous claim its lead over household tasks is under one percentage point. Asked who argues weekly, money comes third behind time together and the children.
- Money is the topic that least often gets resolved. This is the best-supported claim in the literature and it comes from diaries rather than recall: money conflicts last longer, recur more, feel more consequential, and more often end with we'll talk about it later.
- Money arguments predict dissatisfaction strongly and divorce modestly. The same authors' other 2012 paper puts it in one line: "highly predictive of low relationship satisfaction and only mildly predictive of divorce."
- The timing is what carried the divorce result. Frequent money arguments early in a marriage were the only money variable that predicted divorce in that model, and an independent, very small newlywed study found money was the one problem already twice as difficult at the start.
- Asked why their marriage ended, people put money third, fifth or 13th, never first. What comes first is lack of commitment, infidelity, growing apart, not being able to talk.
- "Money" is not one thing. Disagreements about fairness, contribution and trust track worse relationships. Disagreements about ordinary expenses track better ones.
None of that supports monitoring your arguments for a divorce forecast, and the forecasting framing is the part to drop. A couple who never argues about money is not safe — in Britt and Huston's divorce model, reporting that you never argued about money was not significant either way, and the one thing that would most reliably remove money arguments from a relationship is one person giving up on being heard about it.
If you want the question with an answer, it is not do we fight about money. It is what is the money fight actually about, and does it ever finish. Fairness and trust are the two bad flavours, and a disagreement that resurfaces unchanged for years is the signature that this literature keeps picking up, in surveys and in diaries alike. That is a question about a standing disagreement, not a budget — the same thing that turns out to matter in the cohabitation research, where what separated couples was not the lease but whether they had settled what they were to each other first, and in the in-laws research, where what predicted divorce was the two spouses not describing the same situation the same way.
The conflict style test scores the pattern that decides how a long-running disagreement goes, the relationship satisfaction test scores the dimensions the literature actually uses rather than printing a verdict, and the attachment style test covers what you bring to reading any of it. All three score in your browser and send nothing anywhere. More of this under Mindset.
And the person who most needs this page is the one who has just read that their money arguments mean their marriage is ending, on a site that sells divorce. The strongest honest version of that claim is that money arguments are a good sign of how a relationship feels, that the subject tends to be old rather than new, and that whether it is about fairness matters more than how often it comes up. Thirteen years of coverage turned that into a superlative, and the superlative was never in a paper.
Pulling it together
The useful finding in this literature was never a ranking. It is that money is the argument that does not finish — longer, more recurrent, more often ended with a promise to return to it, and more likely to have been difficult from the first year of the marriage. That is a claim about an unresolved standing disagreement, and it is supported in survey data, in diary data and in a small newlywed sample, by different teams using different methods.
What the evidence does not support is the forecast. Money arguments predict how a relationship feels much better than they predict whether it ends; asked directly, divorced people name commitment, infidelity and growing apart ahead of money; and the one quantified version of the claim, published by its own author in 2009, came with a comparison group, a gender asymmetry and a number — all three of which the famous sentence dropped.
So the question worth asking is not how often you argue about money. It is whether the argument is about fairness or trust, which track worse relationships, or about ordinary expenses, which track better ones — and whether it has ever actually been settled.
Frequently asked questions
Are money arguments really the top predictor of divorce?
That sentence is a quote from a Kansas State University press release dated 12 July 2013, not a line from a paper. The underlying study is Dew, Britt and Huston, "Examining the Relationship Between Financial Issues and Divorce," Family Relations 61(4), 615-628, 2012, on 4,574 couples from the National Survey of Families and Households. Its abstract makes a narrower claim: financial disagreements were "the strongest disagreement types to predict divorce," and are "stronger predictors of divorce relative to other common marital disagreements." That is a comparison among the handful of disagreement topics the survey measured, not a claim about everything that predicts divorce. The paper itself is paywalled with no legal free copy, and the same co-author published a second paper in 2012 — free in Kansas State's own repository — concluding that money arguments are "only mildly predictive of divorce."
What do couples actually argue about most?
It depends entirely on how you ask, and the two best measurements disagree on purpose. In the national survey behind the famous claim, money is the topic the most people report having had any disagreement about in the past year — 59.8% of answers, against 59.0% for household tasks, a lead of under one percentage point. Count only people who argue weekly or more and money falls to third, behind spending time together (11.6%) and the children (10.8%). But in the one study that recorded conflicts as they happened — 100 couples keeping diaries of all 748 arguments over 15 days, published by Papp, Cummings and Goeke-Morey in 2009 — money was sixth for husbands (18.3%) and fifth for wives (19.4%). Children came first at 36.4% and 38.9%, followed by chores, communication, leisure and work.
Why do surveys say money and diaries say children?
Because retrospective self-report overestimates money, and the researchers demonstrated it inside one study. Before the diary phase, Papp and colleagues asked the same 100 couples in a lab to name their three hardest topics: husbands said money first, wives said childrearing first, and the topic the couples most often chose to discuss on camera was money. Then the diaries showed money fifth and sixth. Their conclusion was that "laboratory problem-solving tasks may lead to an overestimation of the frequency of money conflicts." Their explanations: money conflicts recur unresolved, so they feel dominant when you summarise a year; and money "may be among the most 'socially acceptable' topics that people can admit arguing about." Saying you argue about money costs nothing. Saying you argue about sex, parenting or whether your partner likes you does.
Is it true that income and debt don't matter, only the arguments?
This is the part of the press-release quote that the open evidence backs cleanly. Britt said "we controlled for income, debt and net worth… it didn't matter how much you made or how much you were worth." In the free companion paper by Dew and Dakin (Journal of Financial Therapy, 2011), using the same survey, logged income, logged assets and logged consumer debt all carried coefficients of about .01 and none reached significance, while money and housework disagreements did. So money arguments are not simply a proxy for being poor. One qualification: separate findings in Dew's 2009 National Marriage Project essay do give assets an independent role — couples with no assets at the start of a 36-month period were "70 percent more likely to divorce" than couples with $10,000 in assets. Having no cushion matters; how big the cushion is beyond that matters less.
Do couples who argue about money more often get divorced?
There is one published effect size and it is more modest than the coverage. Jeffrey Dew reported in "Bank On It," his essay in The State of Our Unions 2009, that couples who disagreed about finances once a week were "over 30 percent more likely to divorce over time than couples who reported disagreeing about finances a few times per month." His footnote attributes the figure to a conference paper presented at the National Council on Family Relations in November 2009 — the work that became the 2012 journal article. The same essay reports an asymmetry the famous quote drops: "for husbands, financial disagreements were the only type of common disagreement that predicted whether they would divorce. For wives, both financial and sexual disagreements predicted divorce, but financial disagreements were a much better predictor."
What do people say actually caused their divorce?
Money appears in every list and tops none of them. Scott, Rhoades, Stanley, Allen and Markman (2013) asked 52 divorced people which items had been a major contributor: lack of commitment 75.0%, infidelity 59.6%, too much conflict and arguing 57.7%, marrying too young 45.1%, financial problems 36.7%, substance abuse 34.6%, domestic violence 23.5%. Amato and Previti (2003), asking open-endedly, found financial problems 13th of 18 themes, named by 2% — behind infidelity (21.6%), incompatibility (19.2%) and drinking or drug use (10.6%). Hawkins and colleagues (2012) found how one's spouse handled money third at 40%, behind growing apart (55%) and not being able to talk together (53%). Stated reasons are unreliable accounts constructed after the fact, so none of this is causal — but note the bias runs toward money, since it is the blameless structural explanation, and money still does not come first.
Does arguing about money mean our relationship is in trouble?
Not on its own, and the most recent research says the content matters far more than the frequency. Peetz and colleagues, in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships in 2023, coded 988 Reddit posts and 481 recalled disagreements from married people, and found the themes split in opposite directions. Disagreements about unfair relative contributions, about job and income, and about a partner's perceived irresponsibility were associated with lower couple satisfaction or lower perceived partner responsiveness. But people whose recent money disagreement was about mundane, day-to-day expenses reported higher perceived responsiveness and higher couple satisfaction than those whose disagreement was not. Bickering about the grocery bill looks like a couple running a household out loud. A standing dispute about whether the split is fair, or whether a partner can be trusted with shared money, is the one with worse outcomes attached.
Is there anything about money arguments that does predict divorce?
The timing, more than the amount. In Britt and Huston's 2012 analysis of the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth, of four money-argument variables tested only one predicted divorce: arguing "often" about money in the early years of marriage, odds ratio 2.62. Neither an increase nor a decrease in money arguments over the marriage was significant, and neither was never arguing about money. The authors' summary: "The only predictive measure of money arguments leading to divorce was a frequent level of arguments in the early years of marriage." A very small independent study points the same way — Williamson and colleagues (2016) found that among wives, management of money was the only one of thirteen problems already markedly harder at the start of the marriage for those who later said it contributed to their divorce (6.6 versus 3.2 in difficulty), while six other problems instead got worse over time. That study had 17 men and 23 women at its first time point, so it is a lead rather than a finding.
Where can I read the original study?
You mostly cannot, and that is part of why the press-release version survived. Dew, Britt and Huston (2012) is behind Wiley's paywall; Unpaywall reports no open-access copy for the DOI and Semantic Scholar records its status as closed. What is free, and far more informative than the coverage, is the surrounding literature: Dew and Dakin's 2011 paper in the Journal of Financial Therapy on the same survey, under a Creative Commons licence; Britt and Huston's own 2012 paper, as an accepted manuscript in Kansas State's K-REx repository; Papp, Cummings and Goeke-Morey's 2009 diary study in PubMed Central; Peetz and colleagues' 2023 paper in PubMed Central; and the National Survey of Families and Households codebook itself, which publishes the exact question wording and the raw response distribution for all seven disagreement topics. All are linked in the sources below.
Sources
What this article draws on. For the broader bibliography see our sources page.
- Kansas State University (2013) — Early financial arguments are a predictor of divorce — the press release of 12 July 2013, carried in full by ScienceDaily and credited to Kansas State. The origin of "Arguments about money is by far the top predictor of divorce… It's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else. It's money — for both men and women," of "it didn't matter how much you made or how much you were worth," and of the claim that money arguments take longer to recover from. Note that the release's own headline says "a predictor," and that it describes the second of three authors as having "conducted a study." The original URL on k-state.edu now returns 404
- Dew, J., Britt, S. & Huston, S. (2012) — Examining the Relationship Between Financial Issues and Divorce. Family Relations, 61(4), 615-628 — the paper the press release was about, published a year earlier. N = 4,574 couples from the National Survey of Families and Households. Its abstract reports financial disagreements as "the strongest disagreement types to predict divorce" and "stronger predictors of divorce relative to other common marital disagreements," and reports that conflict tactics and marital satisfaction fully mediated the association. Paywalled: Unpaywall returns is_oa false with zero open locations for this DOI, and Semantic Scholar records its open-access status as CLOSED. No number from inside the article is cited on this page
- Dew, J. & Dakin, J. (2011) — Financial Disagreements and Marital Conflict Tactics. Journal of Financial Therapy, 2(1), 23-42 — the open-access companion paper on the same survey by the same first author, free under a Creative Commons licence. The source of the five disagreement topics used ("money," "household tasks," "spending time together," "sex," "in-laws"), of the standardised coefficients for heated arguments, of the null coefficients on income, assets and debt, of "in five of the eight analyses, disagreements over housework are as strong of predictors of conflict tactics as financial disagreements," of the reverse-causality test, and of the limitation that "it is an older data set. Marriage relations may have changed since 1992"
- Britt, S. L. & Huston, S. J. (2012) — The Role of Money Arguments in Marriage. Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 33(4), 464-476 — the second 2012 paper, by the author of the famous quote, with a free accepted manuscript in Kansas State's K-REx repository. NLSY79, married women in a first marriage; N = 717 for satisfaction and N = 966 for divorce. The source of "money arguments are highly predictive of low relationship satisfaction and only mildly predictive of divorce," of "the only predictive measure of money arguments leading to divorce was a frequent level of arguments in the early years of marriage," of the odds ratios (2.62 for divorce; 2.38 and 2.44 for satisfaction), of the ranking in which marital duration, age at marriage and having children during marriage all contribute more to the divorce model than money arguments, and of the quoted observation that "virtually no studies exist that support the still popular belief that financial problems are the number one cause of divorce"
- Papp, L. M., Cummings, E. M. & Goeke-Morey, M. C. (2009) — For Richer, for Poorer: Money as a Topic of Marital Conflict in the Home. Family Relations, 58(1), 91-103 — the diary study, free in PubMed Central. 100 husbands and 100 wives, 748 conflicts logged over 15 days in 1999-2000. The source of the full topic table (children 36.4%/38.9%, chores 25.1%/24.1%, communication 22.1%/21.8%, leisure 19.5%/20.1%, work 19.3%/18.9%, money 18.3%/19.4%), of "spouses did not rate money as the most frequent source of marital conflict in the home," of the finding that money conflicts were longer, more recurrent, more important and more often left unresolved, of the lab-versus-home comparison and "laboratory problem-solving tasks may lead to an overestimation of the frequency of money conflicts," and of the point that money may be among the most socially acceptable topics to admit arguing about
- National Survey of Families and Households — Wave 1 codebook — University of Wisconsin-Madison, Center for Demography and Ecology — the published codebook for the self-administered form. Item E706 is the disagreement battery, and this is the source of the verbatim question stem ("The following is a list of subjects on which couples often have disagreements. How often, if at all, in the last year have you had open disagreements about each of the following"), of all seven topics including "having a(nother) child" and "the children," of the six-point response scale, and of the raw frequency distributions from which the "any disagreement" and "weekly or more" percentages on this page were computed
- Dew, J. P. (2009) — Bank On It: Thrifty Couples are the Happiest. The State of Our Unions 2009, National Marriage Project — reached through the Internet Archive, as the original address no longer resolves. The source of the only quantified version of this claim in general circulation: "couples who reported disagreeing about finances once a week were over 30 percent more likely to divorce over time than couples who reported disagreeing about finances a few times per month," footnoted to a conference paper presented at the National Council on Family Relations in November 2009. Also the source of the husband/wife asymmetry, of the 45% "spent money foolishly" figure attributed to Amato and Rogers (1997), and of the 70% figure on couples with no assets
- Peetz, J. et al. (2023) — When couples fight about money, what do they fight about? Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 40(11), 3723-3751 — free in PubMed Central, with open data. 988 coded Reddit posts and 481 recalled disagreements from married people. The source of the fairness and responsibility dimensions, of the finding that "unfair relative contributions," "job and income" and "perceived irresponsibility" track worse outcomes while "mundane expenses" tracks better ones, and of the scholarly description of the 2012 paper's measure: "Couples rated the frequency of disagreements about various topics… such as chores, finances, time spent together, sex, and in-law relations. Only frequency of disagreements about finances and sex were significant predictors of divorce 5-7 years later"
- Scott, S. B., Rhoades, G. K., Stanley, S. M., Allen, E. S. & Markman, H. J. (2013) — Reasons for divorce and recollections of premarital intervention: Implications for improving relationship education. Couple and Family Psychology, 2(2), 131-145 — free in PubMed Central. 52 individuals who received premarital education and divorced within 14 years. The source of the ranking of major contributors to divorce (lack of commitment 75.0%, infidelity 59.6%, conflict and arguing 57.7%, marrying too young 45.1%, financial problems 36.7%, substance abuse 34.6%, domestic violence 23.5%), of participants' own observation that financial difficulties were "not the most pertinent reason" but contributed stress, of the Hawkins and colleagues (2012) and Johnson and colleagues (2001) figures quoted here, and of the asymmetry in who participants thought should have worked harder
- Williamson, H. C., Nguyen, T. P., Karney, B. R. & Bradbury, T. N. (2016) — Are problems that contribute to divorce present at the start of marriage, or do they emerge over time? Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 33(8) — free in the University of California's eScholarship repository. The source of the finding that among wives, "management of money" was the only one of thirteen problems whose starting level differed by later contribution to divorce (6.6 against 3.2), while six other problems instead worsened over time, and of the problem-endorsement percentages. Sample sizes are very small — 17 men and 23 women at the first time point, falling to 5 and 7 by the fourth — and are stated on this page wherever the study is used
- Amato, P. R. & Previti, D. (2003) — People's Reasons for Divorcing: Gender, Social Class, the Life Course, and Adjustment. Journal of Family Issues, 24(5), 602-626 — the open-ended study of why marriages ended. Paywalled; the ranking cited here (financial problems 13th of 18 themes, named by 2% of the sample) is reported as Britt and Huston's own 2012 paper reports it in its literature review, and the top three figures as Scott and colleagues (2013) report them
- Amato, P. R. & Rogers, S. J. (1997) — A Longitudinal Study of Marital Problems and Subsequent Divorce. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 59(3), 612-624 — the source of the strongest money-related finding in this literature: that feeling one's spouse spent money foolishly raised the likelihood of divorce by about 45% for both men and women, with only extramarital affairs and alcohol or drug abuse stronger. Paywalled and not opened for this page; the figure and the ranking appear here only as Dew reports them in The State of Our Unions 2009, and are labelled as such in the text
- CTV News (2013) — Fighting over money is a top predictor of divorce, study shows. 16 July 2013 — an example of the spoken superlative becoming the headline finding four days after the press release
- Soto Nellis, V. (2013) — Bad Pennies: Financial Arguments Top Predictor of Divorce. Lewitt Hackman, 21 August 2013 — a family law firm's post, quoted on this page as a representative example of where the claim now lives. It reproduces Britt's "It's not children, sex, in-laws or anything else" and closes by offering a referral; it is also the only page found that reproduces Dew's actual over-30-percent effect size, and it notes on its own account that "the actual causes of divorce are a bit more complicated"
- Find A Helpline — Free, confidential support services by country — for the note at the top of this page about money being used as a means of control
- National Domestic Violence Hotline — Warning signs of abuse, including controlling a partner's access to money, running up debt in their name, and preventing them from working or studying — the patterns that are economic abuse rather than a disagreement about a budget
Keep reading
- MindsetThinking About Breaking Up: What a National Panel Found Happened NextA quarter of married people had thought about divorce in the past six months. A year later, 31% of them were no longer thinking about it.
- MindsetHow Long Does It Take to Get Over a Breakup? Four Clocks, Four Different AnswersThree of the numbers on the first page of results trace back to one 2007 survey of 155 undergraduates, where the figure was how long ago the breakups were.
- MindsetDoes Living Together Before Marriage Lead to Divorce? Four Things Change the AnswerThe famous 1.31 comes from women under 45 in first marriages. Control for the age they moved in together, not the age they married, and it drops to 1.09.
- DatingDo Opposites Attract? The Largest Study of Couples, and the Number It Actually ReportsThe study everyone quotes measured 133 traits in up to 79,074 couples. Its mean partner correlation is 0.19, and not one page on the first screen reports it.
- MindsetDo Rebound Relationships Work? The Only Experiments Never Put Anybody in OneNot one of the eight readable pages gives a sample size, and the two experiments on the subject never put anybody in a new relationship.
- MindsetDo Couples Stay Together After Infidelity? The Famous 57% Is Eight Couples Out of FourteenThe famous 57% comes from a five-year follow-up of 19 couples: eight of the 14 who disclosed the affair stayed, and one of the five who hid it.