attraction.lab

Cushioning in Dating: What Has Actually Been Measured About Keeping Someone in Reserve

The word has no studies behind it. The behaviour has six, under another name — and the number of people someone keeps in reserve did not predict commitment.

Research-backed writing on attraction, dating and relationships. Drafted by AI against a named bibliography, published only when every claim links to its source.
31 min read
Editorial illustration for: Cushioning in Dating: What Has Actually Been Measured About Keeping Someone in Reserve

Before the article. If reading this is part of being required to hand over a phone, account passwords or your location, or of being asked to account for your time and your friendships, that is a pattern the National Domestic Violence Hotline lists among the warning signs of abuse, and it notes that even one or two is a red flag. In the United States that line is 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788, 24 hours a day. Find A Helpline, in the sources at the bottom, lists free and confidential services by country.

With that said. Cushioning is a dating word for keeping one or two people warm in the background in case the relationship you are in ends. The word has no research behind it — we searched Crossref and OpenAlex and found no study of it in this sense, and English Wikipedia covers only the workplace version, career cushioning.

The behaviour has been studied since 2014 under the name back burners, and the researchers who named it tested exactly the thing the word insinuates. They predicted that the more people somebody kept in reserve, the less committed they would be. The number did not predict commitment at all.

What follows is eighteen sections built on six journal articles, two meta-analyses, a classic study of attention to alternatives, a 3,585-person study of adult crushes and the authors' own plain-language account of their first survey. It covers what the construct actually requires, how common it is, what did predict things, which part carries real information (it is not the count), the disclosure finding that is the honest content of the anxiety, the paper in which the authors doubt their own category, and what nobody has measured.

It contains no method for detecting this in another person, because none exists. Where a paper is paywalled and this page reports from its abstract, the source note says so, which is the promise made in our editorial policy.

#1

The word has no research behind it. The behaviour has had a research name since 2014

Cushioning is a dating-vocabulary word. It means keeping one or two people warm in the background — a few messages a month, a reply to a story, the occasional hey stranger — so that if the relationship you are in comes apart you do not land on concrete.

The word itself has never been studied. We searched Crossref and OpenAlex for it in this sense and found nothing: no paper, no scale, no chapter. English Wikipedia has no entry for it either; the only cushioning it covers is the workplace version, career cushioning, quietly keeping your CV warm in case the job goes.

The behaviour is a different matter. It has been in the peer-reviewed literature since 2014 under the name back burners, it has six journal articles and a doctoral dissertation behind it, and the researchers who named it have measured the exact thing the dating word is used to insinuate. That is better than its nearest neighbour manages: breadcrumbing does have research under its own name, but the whole of it is three papers and a single survey item.

Their central result is not the one the word implies. Before collecting any data they predicted that the more people somebody kept on the back burner, the less committed they would be to their current partner. The number did not predict commitment at all.

That is the headline, and the rest of this page is about why it is more interesting than it sounds — what the construct actually requires, what did predict things, which part of the behaviour genuinely carries information (it is not the count), what nobody has measured, and why the obvious remedy has been tested and backfired.

Most of these papers sit behind paywalls. Where this page reports from a published abstract rather than from a method section, the source note says so, which is the promise made in our editorial policy.

#2

What a back burner is, in the definition the research uses

The construct is narrower than the magazine word, and the three things that narrow it are the whole reason it can be studied at all.

Jayson Dibble and Michelle Drouin defined a back burner as a desired prospective romantic or sexual partner with whom a person communicates in order to establish a future romantic or sexual connection. That definition has been carried unchanged through every paper since.

Communication is constitutive. Without contact there is no back burner. Somebody you think about and never message is a crush, which is a separate thing with a separate literature and a far larger sample, covered further down. This is the single most useful distinction on this page, because the dating word collapses the two.

You are not currently involved with them. A back burner is by definition someone you are not romantically or sexually involved with right now. A former partner qualifies, as long as that has stopped — which is how the summary of the literature in a 2021 doctoral dissertation on back-burner maintenance reads it.

Nothing about your own status is specified. Singles have them. So do people in committed relationships. The construct does not assume betrayal and does not assume sex; it describes a line of communication kept open with an intention attached.

Notice what that leaves out. Nothing in the definition is about hiding, about insurance against a breakup, or about a partner's right to know. Those are the parts the word cushioning supplies for free. They are reasonable things to care about. They are not what the construct measures, and keeping them apart is what makes the findings below readable.

#3

How common it is, and the two numbers to know first

The prevalence figures come from the authors' own plain-language account of their first study, published in The Conversation in February 2018, because the 2014 paper is paywalled and we could not read its method section.

More than 70% of their sample reported having at least one back burner. Among the students they surveyed, singles averaged about six and people in committed relationships averaged almost five.

Sit with the second number for a moment. The gap between being single and being committed was roughly one person. Whatever keeping a few embers alive is, it is not something that mostly stops when a relationship starts.

A later study by the same group, with 658 students, found the same oddity from a different angle: the number of back burners reported by singles did not differ from the number reported by people in committed romances. That is two looks at the same strange fact, although from the same research group rather than from independent labs, which is worth holding in mind.

The limits are the usual ones and they are real. These are undergraduates at American universities, surveyed once, reporting on themselves, in a period when the technology that makes this frictionless was newer than it is now. Nobody has published a prevalence figure for people in their thirties, for married couples, or for anyone outside a campus — the authors say so themselves, noting that they have heard married people describe a person or two they would probably end up with if their spouse died, and that this has never been tested in a scientific setting.

So: common among young adults, probably common more widely, and unmeasured outside that group. That is the honest state of the prevalence question.

#4

The prediction the researchers made, and the result that broke it

This is the part that answers the search, so it goes without hedging first and with caveats after.

Dibble and Drouin built their first study on commitment theory. If commitment is partly a function of how good your alternatives look, then somebody actively texting six alternatives should be less committed than somebody texting none. They wrote that prediction down before gathering data.

In their own words afterwards: the number of back burners people reported did not predict how committed they were to their partners. We can't infer how committed people are just by knowing how many back burners they may or may not have.

They call the result surprising, and they are careful about it in a way the coverage of this subject never is: one study, they say, and more research is needed to determine how reliable the finding is.

Their own speculation about why is worth repeating because it is testable and nobody has tested it. Back-burner communication today is easy to sustain and easy to keep separate — contact lists can be hidden, names can be changed, messages can be deleted — and they wonder whether mobile communication creates enough distance from offline life that the two can run in parallel without one draining the other.

What the result licenses is narrow and still worth having. A count is not a reading. If you have arrived here holding a number — how many people they still message, how many names are in that app — the one study that put that number next to a measure of commitment found it carried no information about commitment. That is not a verdict that everything is fine. It is a reason to stop treating the count as the instrument, and the next two sections are about what the instrument actually is.

#5

Why the count was expected to matter, and what the model really says

The theory behind the failed prediction is the best-supported framework in this whole area, which is why its mismatch with the count is instructive rather than embarrassing.

Caryl Rusbult's investment model holds that commitment rests on three things: how satisfied you are, how good your alternatives look, and how much you have put in. Benjamin Le and Christopher Agnew's meta-analysis — 52 studies, 60 independent samples, 11,582 participants — found all three associated with commitment (satisfaction r = .68, alternatives r = −.48, investment r = .46), together accounting for close to two-thirds of the variance in commitment, with commitment in turn predicting whether relationships survived. The scale that measures all four constructs was published by Rusbult, John Martz and Agnew in 1998 and is still the standard instrument.

Now look closely at the middle variable. It is the perceived quality of your alternatives: whether you believe you would be fine, or better, if this ended. It is a judgement about a counterfactual life.

A back burner count is not that. It is a tally of open conversations. Two people with identical tallies can hold completely different beliefs about whether they would be fine alone, and two people who both believe they would be fine can have tallies of six and zero.

That is almost certainly why the prediction failed: the study substituted a behavioural proxy for a perceptual variable, and the proxy was poor. It is also why the popular version of this question is badly posed. How many people are they talking to is answerable and uninformative. How good do they think their options are is informative and not answerable from outside — which is why our relationship satisfaction test scores alternatives as a separate number instead of folding it into how happy somebody says they are, and why the research on why people stay in relationships that are not working spends most of its length on that distinction.

#6

Counting is not watching, and watching is the thing that was measured

There is a variable in this area that predicted relationship failure better than anything else in its study, and it is not a count of contacts. It is attention.

Rowland Miller ran it in 1997. Participants described their relationships, then sat through slides of attractive opposite-sex targets while the time they spent on each was recorded, and two months later reported whether the relationship had ended.

Three results, in order of usefulness. Satisfaction with, investment in, commitment to and adjustment in the relationship were all negatively correlated with self-reported vigilance toward desirable alternatives. People who had earlier said they were attentive to alternatives really did linger on the pictures, so the self-report was not just talk. And in Miller's own summary, there was no better predictor of relationship failure than high attentiveness to alternatives.

His reading is that inattention is a maintenance mechanism rather than a personality trait — something relationships do, not something good people are. The line he closes on is the one worth remembering: even if the grass is greener on the other side of the fence, happy gardeners are less likely to notice.

The caveats: one study, one cohort, a slide-show design from the 1990s, opposite-sex targets only, and two months of follow-up. It has not been replicated with the same behavioural measure.

But the distinction it draws is the sharpest thing in this subject. Vigilance is the marker. Contacts are not. Someone can keep five faint embers alive out of sentiment, habit and bad boundaries without ever comparing. Someone else can compare relentlessly and message nobody. The dating word points at the contact list, which is visible. The research points at the comparing, which is not.

That gap is the same one micro-cheating falls into, and the numbers there are worth putting next to Miller's. When 456 people were asked to rate 27 behaviours for how far each indicated cheating, the visible ambiguous ones — dinner, a long hug, confiding in someone else, frequent messaging — landed around the middle of the scale with standard deviations of 30 to 35 points, meaning the population is split rather than undecided. A contact list can be audited. Where the line sits cannot be read off it.

#7

The disclosure finding, and it is the part that stings

If any result in this literature deserves the anxiety the word cushioning carries, it is this one.

Dibble, Drouin, Krystyna Aune and Robert Boller ran two surveys, with 347 and 374 participants, and reported four things from them.

Back-burner communication is relatively common among college students. Those same students have many romantic or sexual interests whom they do not consider back burners, which means the category is genuinely narrower than everyone I find attractive and that people can tell the difference. Most of them will not fully disclose their back-burner communication to their partners. And roughly half fully disclose their communication with people they find romantically or sexually desirable.

The asymmetry is the finding. The same population is markedly more willing to admit to the attraction than to the contact. Whatever the word cushioning is reaching for, this is it: not the existence of other people, which is ordinary and nearly universal, but the gap between what gets said and what gets done.

The authors' own inference is that non-disclosure suggests some uneasiness about being caught, which is a reasonable reading of their data and is still an inference. What was measured is what people say they would disclose. Nobody surveyed the partners. Nobody has compared what people report disclosing with what they actually disclosed, and there is no study of what happens in a relationship when a back burner is disclosed or discovered.

So the honest version is this: the secrecy is real and it is measured, and the consequences of the secrecy are not. That is a smaller claim than the genre makes and a larger one than the count supports.

#8

Who keeps them, and the personality profile that is mostly not there

The second thing the word cushioning smuggles in is a character verdict: that this is what a certain kind of person does. That has been tested, and it mostly did not come out.

Dana Borzea and Megan Dillow measured sociosexual orientation, sensation seeking, narcissism, Machiavellianism and the Big Five against the number of back burners maintained, in both single and romantically involved young adults.

Considered one at a time, two things showed up: every dimension of unrestricted sociosexual orientation — roughly, openness to uncommitted sex in behaviour, attitude and desire — and high sensation seeking were positively associated with the number of back burners.

Then they let the predictors compete, and only one survived. Unrestricted sociosexual behaviour significantly predicted the number of back burners. Narcissism did not. Machiavellianism did not. None of the Big Five did.

Two things follow. The first is that the surviving predictor is a behaviour, not a trait verdict — what somebody reports having done, not what kind of person a questionnaire says they are. The second is that it leaves most of the variance unaccounted for, which is the usual and usually unreported state of personality prediction.

This is the same mistake this site has had to unpick in a neighbouring construct. In the research on falling in love fast, the most-quoted number is a correlation between a person's own score and their own narcissism, which gets reported as a finding about who they date. The dark-traits reading of back burners does not even have that: here the dark traits were measured, put in the same model, and dropped out.

#9

Status changes the conversation, not the contact list

The 2018 study is where the literature starts locating the difference in the right place.

Dibble, Narissra Punyanunt-Carter and Drouin surveyed 658 college students about how much they used three well-established positive maintenance strategies — positivity, openness and assurances — when communicating with their most important back burner. These are the same behaviours relationship researchers have measured for decades in romantic relationships and friendships: being cheerful and pleasant, talking openly about the relationship, and signalling a future.

The number of back burners did not differ by relationship status, consistent with the earlier work. What differed was what people did with them. Singles and casual daters used the positive maintenance strategies to a greater extent than people in committed relationships did. Men reported using more assurances than women; the sexes did not differ on the other two.

That is a more sensible picture than either the null or the panic. A single person with five back burners is, on average, actively tending five possibilities. A committed person with five is, on average, tending them less. The count is the same and the activity is not, and only one of those is visible from the outside.

It also explains why a partner going through a phone finds the question harder rather than easier. What distinguishes these cases is the register of the messages — warmth, openness about where this could go, the small promises that signal a future — and register is exactly what survives badly out of context. Somebody who reads a two-year-old thread looking for assurances will find something that could be read as one. What goes wrong when a phone becomes the evidence in a relationship is the longer version of that problem.

Further illustration for: Cushioning in Dating: What Has Actually Been Measured About Keeping Someone in Reserve
#10

Then the count got split in two, and the picture sharpened

In 2023 the same group did the thing that should have been done first: they stopped treating a back burner count as one number.

With 762 college students, they separated the back burners people communicated with romantically or sexually from those they communicated with in a strictly platonic way, and asked about sex, relationship status and love styles.

The split changed the answer. Men reported more of the romantic or sexual kind than women did. Singles and casual daters averaged more of the romantic or sexual kind than people in committed relationships did — the status difference that the undifferentiated count had hidden for nine years. And the platonic counts did not differ by sex or by relationship status at all.

The love-style results point the same way. A more ludic style — love approached as a game, with several people in play and none of it taken too heavily — went with more back burners overall. A more storgic style — love as friendship that deepens — went with fewer of the romantic or sexual kind.

The authors' own conclusion is the sentence to take away: sex and relationship status may matter less to the wholesale practice of keeping back burners, and more to the nature of the communication with them.

This is a literature correcting itself in public, and the corrected version is more useful than either the original null or the magazine version. The thing worth knowing is not whether somebody has people in reserve. Almost everybody does, and the platonic half of that is apparently invariant. It is whether the line being kept open is being kept open romantically.

#11

The study that asks whether any of these categories exist

This is the most uncomfortable paper in the set, and the one most relevant to a word invented by a magazine.

In 2019 Dibble, Drouin and Punyanunt-Carter ran an experiment with 327 participants to locate back burners on the spectrum of casual sexual and relational experiences, comparing them against two neighbours with their own established literatures: friends with benefits and hookups.

One difference emerged. Participants reported more sex with friends with benefits and with hookups than with back burners, which is close to definitional.

On everything else, nothing. No differences in friendship strength, relationship closeness, passion, commitment, frequency of communication, or willingness to self-disclose.

The authors' own conclusion is printed in the abstract and deserves quoting rather than paraphrasing: the conceptual distinctions between these relationship types may be experimenter-created and not reflective of the fluidity of these definitions in young adults.

That is researchers saying, in print, that the boxes they built may be theirs rather than the world's. Six of seven dimensions did not separate a category with a decade of papers behind it from the categories next to it.

Which is the right frame for the word this page is named after. If careful operational definitions, tested experimentally, do not carve this behaviour at a joint, a term coined for a lifestyle column is not going to. This site keeps arriving at the same place from different directions: the three-day rule and the 3-6-9 rule are both numbers with no origin, pocketing is a name for something the research describes in narrower and less damning terms, and here is a construct whose own authors suspect the category is an artefact. The vocabulary expands faster than the measurement, and it expands in the direction of blame.

#12

Crushes are not back burners, and that distinction has the biggest sample

Everything above runs on undergraduates in the hundreds. The largest adult sample in this neighbourhood studies the thing the dating word keeps confusing with it, and it is the strongest counterweight on this page.

Lucia O'Sullivan, Charlene Belu and Justin Garcia surveyed 3,585 participants aged 22 to 45, 53.1% of them women, across three studies and four datasets, about crushes: attractions that are typically uncommunicated and often one-sided. They compared people in committed relationships with single people, asked what the crush seemed to be doing for them, and asked what they expected would come of it.

The results run against the panic in three ways.

People in committed relationships typically did not intend to communicate the attraction at all, unlike the single participants. The perceived outcomes were primarily positive — excitement, a lift in self-regard, fantasy and escape — rather than distress or guilt. And the vast majority reported no expectation that the crush would turn into anything more intimate, let alone replace the relationship they were in.

That is the common case, in adults rather than students, at a sample size an order of magnitude above the rest of this literature: an attraction that is deliberately not acted on, is experienced as pleasant, and is not expected to go anywhere.

The construct that this page is actually about is the narrower, rarer one. A back burner requires the thing the crush research found most people withhold: contact, with intent attached. If what is happening is an unacted-on attraction, the word cushioning is not describing it, and neither is any finding above.

#13

Does it predict a breakup? Nobody has measured it

The question everybody arrives with is whether this means the relationship is doomed, and the answer has to be a plain admission before it can be anything else.

No study has followed people with back burners and recorded what happened to their relationships. Not at six months, not at two years, not ever. The authors said so themselves in 2018 — they do not have a firm answer, and they note that since communication is required for someone to count as a back burner, this may up the ante relative to merely noticing alternatives.

What exists in the neighbourhood is the largest synthesis of breakup predictors anyone has run. Le, Natalie Dove, Agnew, Miriam Korn and Amelia Mutso meta-analysed 137 studies and 37,761 participants over 33 years. The strongest predictors of a non-marital relationship ending were commitment, love, inclusion of the other in the self, and dependence. Satisfaction, perceptions of alternatives and investments were modest predictors. Social network support was robust. Personality measures had limited predictive utility, with small effects for the relational dimensions such as attachment.

Read that against the count. Even the perceptual variable the count is a poor proxy for is only a modest predictor of breakup, and the strong predictors are all about the relationship you are in rather than the ones you are not.

There is also a more direct question than any of this. Laura VanderDrift, Agnew and Juan Wilson developed a measure of dissolution consideration — how salient ending the relationship already is to you while it is still intact — and found it mediates between low commitment and actually leaving, predicting leave behaviour beyond commitment alone. If what you want to know is whether somebody is on their way out, how often they have thought about leaving is a better question than how many people are in their phone, and the first one can be asked.

#14

The obvious remedy has been tested, and it backfired

The folk response to all of this is to cut it off: delete them, unfollow, stop looking. That instruction has been tested in the laboratory, and the result is the most counterintuitive thing on this page.

The background first. There is a line of work showing that people in committed relationships automatically pay less attention to attractive alternatives — a maintenance mechanism running below deliberate control, documented by Jon Maner and colleagues in 2008 and 2009. We cite those two for the existence of the research line; their abstracts are not public and we could not read the methods.

What has been read is what happens when that inattention is imposed from outside. Nathan DeWall, Maner, Timothy Deckman and Aaron Rouby ran three experiments under the heading forbidden fruit. Subtly limiting people's attention to attractive alternatives reduced relationship satisfaction and commitment and increased positive attitudes toward infidelity in the first experiment, increased memory for attractive alternatives in the second, and increased attention to them in the third. Their conclusion is that although attention to alternatives can harm a relationship, situations that implicitly limit that attention can increase the temptation and undermine the relationship instead.

Set beside that an older and sturdier result. Dennis Johnson and Rusbult ran three studies on devaluation of alternatives. Longitudinally, the perceived quality of alternatives decreased over time among people who stayed and increased among people who left. In a computer-dating paradigm, the most committed participants devalued alternatives most under the highest threat. In a simulation, rejecting and devaluing alternatives was greater under high commitment. In all three, devaluation tracked commitment more closely than satisfaction.

Put the two together and the practical reading is unusually clear. The turning-away is real, and it is downstream of commitment — it happens on its own when the relationship is working. The one manipulation that resembles enforcing it from outside produced the opposite of what it was meant to produce. The limits matter: these were brief laboratory manipulations with photographs of strangers, not partners imposing rules on each other, so this is a reason to doubt the remedy rather than proof that it fails in life.

#15

What none of this licenses, and it needs saying plainly

The predictable use of a page like this is as grounds for an audit. It does not support one, and the audit has its own literature.

There is a measured route from feeling second to a partner's phone toward monitoring that partner. Janneke Schokkenbroek, Wim Hardyns and Koen Ponnet surveyed 346 people and traced a path from perceived phubbing, to lower perceived partner responsiveness, to anxiety, to electronic partner surveillance — with the authors' own caution, which is usually dropped when the study is quoted, that the model explains around 5% of the variance. It is a small effect describing a real path, and the path runs from distress to checking.

That is the honest version of what checking is: a response to feeling unsure, not an instrument that resolves it. No audit of a contact list returns the quantity anyone actually wants, because the quantity anyone actually wants is somebody's intent, and intent is not stored in a phone.

And there is a line that is not about effect sizes. Requiring access to a partner's phone, accounts or location; requiring them to account for their time; cutting them off from their own people; treating their judgement as the obstacle — the National Domestic Violence Hotline lists behaviours of this kind among the warning signs of abuse, and notes that even one or two is a red flag. In the United States that line is 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788, 24 hours a day. Find A Helpline, in the sources below, lists free and confidential services by country.

That applies in both directions. If you are the one being asked to produce a phone to prove the absence of something, the request is not a measurement. The distinction between a feeling and a behaviour, and the point at which jealousy turns into control, is set out with its evidence in the psychology of jealousy.

#16

If you are the one with the list

Three things the evidence supports, and one it has no standing on.

The count is common and uninformative on its own. Seven people in ten in the first study had at least one. The number did not predict commitment. That is not permission and it is not absolution; it is a reason to stop treating the tally as the measurement, because the one study that tried found it was not one.

The measured risk marker is vigilance. Miller's question is a better one to ask yourself than any question about contacts: are you comparing? Not whether somebody attractive exists, but whether you find yourself running the arithmetic — would I be better off, is this one better than mine. That is the variable that predicted relationships ending, and it is available to you by introspection in a way a partner's intent never is.

The disclosure gap is the useful signal, and it points inward. Most people in the 2015 study would not fully disclose back-burner communication, while about half would disclose the attraction itself. If there is a conversation you would not have, the thing worth examining is the gap, not the contact. Gaps of that shape are also what the research on keeping a relationship out of sight is about, from the other side.

And the thing the research has no standing on: whether this counts as cheating. That is not an empirical question. It is an agreement between two people about what they have agreed, and no study in this literature has any authority over it. Anyone telling you the science says it is or is not betrayal is telling you their own view with a citation stapled to it. What the research can do is stop the argument being conducted over the wrong number.

#17

If you think someone is cushioning you

Start with what is genuinely unavailable to you, because the genre pretends otherwise.

You cannot see their count, and if you could it would not tell you what you want. You cannot see their intent, and intent is the only part of the definition that separates a back burner from a dormant acquaintance. The one study that asked adults in committed relationships about intent found that most did not mean to act, and expected nothing to come of it.

What is available is the relationship you are in, and it has markers with better evidence behind them than any contact list.

Asymmetric commitment. In the research covered in what a situationship actually is, around a third of couples who were both surveyed showed a substantial gap between the two partners' commitment levels. A relationship with somebody holding options in reserve is one of the shapes that gap takes, and the gap itself is measurable in a way the reserve is not.

Concealment and visibility. Whether you are part of their world or kept beside it has been studied directly, and it predicts more than what is in their messages.

Their own exit question. Dissolution consideration — how present the idea of ending it already is — predicts leaving better than commitment alone, and unlike everything else here it can be asked out loud.

Which is where this subject lands, again. The instrument that resolves an ambiguous situation is a direct question, asked plainly, with the answer treated as information. Whether a relationship has real potential is built almost entirely out of things you can observe together rather than things you have to detect, and that is not a consolation prize. It is what the measurement keeps pointing at.

#18

What this evidence cannot tell you

The limits belong on the page, in the same size type as the findings.

It cannot tell you that the word means anything. Cushioning has no literature, no definition anyone agreed on, and no measurement. Everything above is about a different, narrower construct that researchers built and may not have carved correctly — their own 2019 experiment raises exactly that doubt.

It cannot tell you about anyone over about 25. Five of the six back-burner studies are American undergraduates, in samples of a few hundred, surveyed once. The only large adult sample on this page is the crush research, and crushes are not back burners.

It cannot tell you that the count is harmless. The one study that tested it against commitment found nothing, and the authors wrote that one study is not enough to know how reliable that is. Absence of a finding in a single sample is not evidence of absence.

It cannot tell you what happens next. No longitudinal study of back burners exists. Nobody has recorded whether these relationships ended, or what happened when a back burner was discovered.

It is almost all self-report, collected once. Including the disclosure finding, which is what people say they would disclose rather than what they did.

And most of it is paywalled. What this page reports from four of these papers comes from published abstracts, and from the authors' own plain-language summary of the first study. That is stated in the source list rather than hidden in it.

What survives is small and real. Keeping a few lines open is ordinary rather than exceptional, and roughly as ordinary in a relationship as out of one. The number says nothing on its own; what varies with relationship status is the register of the conversation, not the tally. The measured risk marker is comparing, not contacts. Most people do not disclose it, and that gap is the honest content of the anxiety. And nobody has measured whether any of it predicts an ending. More in Dating, our attachment style test prints two dimensions and says on the page what it is not, and the claims this site has retracted are listed on the corrections page.

Pulling it together

If one thing survives, it is that the question is usually asked about the wrong number. Keeping a few lines open is ordinary — more than seven in ten people in the first study had at least one, and people in committed relationships averaged barely fewer than singles. The count, tested directly against commitment, carried no information about commitment. What varies with relationship status is not the tally but the register of the conversation: singles and casual daters tend the possibilities more actively, and the 2023 study that split romantic contacts from platonic ones found the status difference lived entirely in the romantic half.

The second thing is where the real marker sits. Vigilance toward alternatives — the comparing, the running arithmetic — was the best predictor of relationship failure in the study that measured it. That is available to you about yourself and unavailable to you about anybody else.

The third is the part that earns the anxiety. Most people would not fully disclose this to a partner, while about half would disclose the attraction itself. The gap between what gets said and what gets done is the honest content of the word, and it is smaller and more specific than the accusation the word carries.

And the fourth is a gap, not a finding: nobody has followed people with back burners to see whether their relationships ended.

Frequently asked questions

What does cushioning mean in dating?

It is a popular term for keeping one or more potential partners in contact in the background, so that there is a soft landing if the current relationship ends. It has no research literature at all: a search of Crossref and OpenAlex returns no study of the term in this sense, and English Wikipedia has no entry for it beyond the workplace version, career cushioning. The behaviour does have a research name. Since 2014 it has been studied as "back burners," defined by Jayson Dibble and Michelle Drouin as a desired prospective romantic or sexual partner with whom a person communicates in order to establish a future romantic or sexual connection. The research definition is narrower than the dating word in one important way: communication is required. Someone you think about and never message is a crush, which is a separate thing with a far larger body of evidence behind it.

Does having back burners mean someone is less committed?

The one study that tested this found no association. Dibble and Drouin predicted, before collecting data, that more back burners would go with less commitment to a current partner, and in their own words afterwards, the number of back burners people reported did not predict how committed they were. They are careful about it — one study, and more research is needed to know how reliable the finding is — so this is not proof that the count is harmless. It is a reason to stop treating the count as the measurement. The variable the investment model actually uses is the perceived quality of your alternatives, meaning whether you believe you would be fine if this ended, and that is a judgement rather than a tally. In Le and Agnew's meta-analysis of 52 studies and 11,582 participants, perceived quality of alternatives correlated with commitment at r = −.48.

How many back burners does the average person have?

In the only prevalence figures published, taken from the authors' own plain-language account of their first study because the paper is paywalled, more than 70% of their sample reported at least one. Singles averaged about six and people in committed relationships averaged almost five — a gap of roughly one person. A later study of 658 students by the same group found that the number did not differ by relationship status at all. All of these are American undergraduates surveyed once, so there is no published figure for anyone in their thirties, for married couples, or for any population off a campus. The 2023 study of 762 students did find a status difference once it separated back burners communicated with romantically or sexually from strictly platonic ones: the difference was entirely in the romantic half, and the platonic counts did not differ by sex or status.

Is cushioning the same as cheating?

That is not a question research can answer, and anyone citing a study for it is stapling a citation to their own opinion. Whether contact with someone else counts as a betrayal is an agreement between two people about what they have agreed, and none of this literature has standing over it. What the research can do is keep the argument off the wrong number. The construct does not assume betrayal: it describes an open line of communication with an intention attached, and it applies to single people as much as to committed ones. The finding that comes closest to the concern is about disclosure rather than contact — most people in the 2015 study said they would not fully disclose their back-burner communication to a partner, while roughly half would disclose communication with people they simply found desirable.

What are the signs someone is cushioning you?

There are none that have been validated, and the structure of the construct explains why. A back burner is defined partly by intent — communicating with somebody in order to establish a future romantic or sexual connection — and intent is not visible in a contact list, a reply time or a thread. The closest the literature comes is the 2018 finding that singles and casual daters use positivity, openness and assurances with their most important back burner more than committed people do, which locates the difference in the register of the messages rather than their number. Register is exactly what reads badly out of context, which is why going through a phone tends to make the question harder. What can be looked at instead is the relationship you are in: asymmetric commitment, which showed up in roughly a third of couples where both partners were surveyed, and how present the idea of ending it already is, which predicts leaving better than commitment alone and can be asked out loud.

Why do people keep back burners?

Nobody has measured motives directly, but one study has tested who does it. Dana Borzea and Megan Dillow put sociosexual orientation, sensation seeking, narcissism, Machiavellianism and the Big Five against the number of back burners maintained. Considered independently, every dimension of unrestricted sociosexual orientation and high sensation seeking were positively associated. When the predictors competed, only unrestricted sociosexual behaviour survived — narcissism did not, Machiavellianism did not, and none of the Big Five did. That is worth knowing because the popular framing treats this as a character verdict. The surviving predictor is a behaviour someone reports having done, and it leaves most of the variance unexplained. The 2023 love-style results point the same way: a game-playing approach to love went with more back burners, and a friendship-based one with fewer of the romantic kind.

Is it still cushioning if they never act on it?

By the research definition, it was never a back burner in the first place, and this distinction has the largest sample in the area behind it. Lucia O'Sullivan, Charlene Belu and Justin Garcia surveyed 3,585 adults aged 22 to 45 about crushes, across three studies and four datasets. People in committed relationships typically did not intend to communicate the attraction at all, unlike single participants; the perceived outcomes were primarily positive, including excitement, a lift in self-regard and fantasy or escape; and the vast majority reported no expectation that the crush would become more intimate or replace their relationship. So the common adult case is an attraction deliberately not acted on and not expected to go anywhere. A back burner requires the part most people in that study withheld, which is contact with intent attached.

Should you delete your back burners?

The one experiment that resembles enforcing that produced the opposite of what it was meant to. Nathan DeWall, Jon Maner, Timothy Deckman and Aaron Rouby ran three studies under the heading "forbidden fruit": subtly limiting people's attention to attractive alternatives reduced relationship satisfaction and commitment and increased positive attitudes toward infidelity, increased memory for attractive alternatives, and increased attention to them. Set against that, Dennis Johnson and Caryl Rusbult found that turning away from alternatives happens by itself and downstream of commitment — perceived quality of alternatives fell over time among people who stayed and rose among those who left, and devaluation tracked commitment more closely than satisfaction. The caveat is real: these were brief laboratory manipulations using photographs of strangers, not partners imposing rules, so it is a reason to doubt the remedy rather than proof that it fails in life.

Is "back burner" even a real category?

Its own authors have published a reason to doubt it. In 2019, Dibble, Drouin and Narissra Punyanunt-Carter ran an experiment with 327 participants comparing back burners against friends with benefits and hookups across an array of dimensions. Participants reported more sex with friends with benefits and hookups, which is close to definitional. On everything else — friendship strength, relationship closeness, passion, commitment, frequency of communication and willingness to self-disclose — no differences emerged. The authors conclude in the abstract that the conceptual distinctions between these relationship types may be experimenter-created and not reflective of the fluidity of these definitions in young adults. If carefully operationalised categories, tested experimentally, fail to separate on six of seven dimensions, a term coined for a lifestyle column is unlikely to be carving anything either.

Sources

What this article draws on. For the broader bibliography see our sources page.

Keep reading